2 Reasons Why Root Cause Isn’t Important

Root cause analysis and root cause failure analysis are commonly used terms. I have always felt that these terms are somewhat misguided.

First, there is not really such a thing as a “root cause” to a problem.

If you try to find a definition for “root cause”, you will find a mix of homegrown attempts, but all of them are general or unclear in nature. Here is an example: “A root cause is an initiating cause of a causal chain which leads to an outcome or effect of interest”.

Aside from being wrong, it is quite a word salad of nonsense. The problem with definitions like these is that it is never, in the real world, possible to prove a single event that solely initiates a whole chain of other events.

This is because there are always other events before the so-called “root cause event”. This may seem like semantics, but for problem-solvers, it is important to keep in mind that there never is a silver-bullet answer.

Second, is finding the root really that important?

In my opinion, the process should be used to implement solutions.

That is the whole idea, isn’t it? – to find and implement SOLUTIONS! If we think logically in reverse and ask, “Do we always have to know the root to find great solutions?” Absolutely not!

A root cause example in manufacturing

A plant has problems with failing bearings in most of its rotating equipment. After a quick look, we find out that equipment isn’t aligned; there are no lubrication routes set up, no clean oil storage, and no sealed storage for spare bearings.

root cause

 

Poor storage of bearings was a finding of a root cause investigation

Learn the proper way to store bearings.

Many people that get excited in doing these investigations become too detailed oriented and lose sight of the big picture and the economics of things.

So, in summary, focus more on implementing solutions based on a practical investigations and not getting to the root.

IDCON calls our method Root Cause Problem Elimination™ (RCPE) to shift the focus towards implementation of solutions rather than just analysis.  Learn more about IDCON’s consulting and training in RCPE.

At IDCON, we understand the pressure you face trying to build a reliable plant.
We provide side-by-side reliability and maintenance consulting and training designed to keep your equipment running.

For over 45 years, we’ve partnered with 100s of manufacturing plants around the world to eliminate the costs and the pressure caused by unreliable equipment. And we’d love to do the same for you.

Contact us today to see how we can help you keep your plant running.

Related Articles

Root Cause Failure Analysis

Root Cause Failure Analysis – IDCON’s Root Cause Problem Elimination Process We have named our process for problem solving training and elimination “Root Cause Problem Elimination™” instead of the commonly used

Read More »
Torbjörn Idhammar

Torbjörn Idhammar

President & CEO, IDCON Inc. Reliability and Maintenance Consultant

Want weekly Reliability & Maintenance Tips?

Weekly Tip Signup Form

Best practices. Common sense. Pratical tips.
All designed to help you and your team keep your plant running

IDCON © 2020 All rights reserved

8-step-checklist-preventive-maintenance-program-download
Free Download & Video

8 Steps to Successfully Implement Preventive Maintenance

Reduce your costs with an effective PM program